民间中医网

 找回密码
 立刻加入
查看: 8295|回复: 21

一天喝八杯水到底是哪个损人的主意?哈佛大学带我们追寻历史!

[复制链接]
发表于 2012/2/19 17:19:51 | 显示全部楼层 |阅读模式
欢迎大家转载!
一天喝八杯水到底是哪个损人的主意?哈佛大学带我们追寻历史!

民间中医网 david92003原创,www.ngotcm.com

一直对每天喝多少水有疑问,尤其是那个被大家传诵的一日八杯的神话。今天有点时间搜寻了这个说法的出处和历史,让我们还原历史的真相,让我们更加了解无知的无畏和所谓专家们建议的无知和可怕。

先告诉大家人家正统西医的结论:喝八杯水是以讹传讹

我简单介绍一下,有耐心您可以自己看。

喝八杯水的说法传自哪里:
遥远的1940年,美国国家学术科学发表了对于一个典型的每天摄入2000大卡热量的食谱来说,需要超过8杯的水来燃烧这些食物。而且这个文章也解释了这些水分是包含从食物中的水分,也就是把你吃的食物内的水分和喝的水算在一起,是8杯(cup)。

大家要注意这里说的杯是cup,这个cup在欧美是一个量具,也就是大家现在米煲或者电饭煲里面带的那个杯子的大小。不知道英美的那个损人把这个cup给变了,居然说成是glass的杯子了,这就是把原来的学术的cup,变成8玻璃杯了。

而今天我们一些的营养专家们更是以讹传讹,绘声绘色的告诉我们要每天喝8玻璃杯水了,至于一杯是多少,我们国人更是八仙过海各显神通了,看办公室里面大家的杯子呵呵,个个是超级巨无霸,这要8杯水下来,完全是可以洗淋浴用了。

要知道,过多的饮水,是造成肝肾的负担,严重影响身体的健康。

真正的喝水原则应该是渴了就喝,每次少喝,再渴再喝。即可。


附录是英文原件,来自哈佛健康杂志的原文。


                               
登录/注册后可看大图
How      much water should you drink?

                               
登录/注册后可看大图
We’ve heard it for decades:        Drink at least 8 cups of water a day. Not only can three out of four        adults recite this bit of health wisdom, but many even feel guilty if        they don’t meet the standard. However, this advice may be based        on a misunderstanding. Some trace it to the 1940s, when the National        Academy of Sciences published a recommended daily allowance of 1 milliliter        of fluid for each calorie burned—a little over 8 cups for a typical        2,000-calorie diet. However, the statement also explained that most of        this fluid could be obtained via the liquid contained in foods.
      Regardless, the 8-glasses-a-day dictum caught on. Today people frequently        consume much more as they tote giant water bottles, buy super-size soft        drinks, and follow programs that promise you can lose weight by drinking        as much as a quart of fluid at a time.
      Also, those who choose to participate in such a diet may forget an important        fact if they’re coffee drinkers: Caffeine is a diuretic – it        encourages the kidneys to produce urine so effectively that it may contribute        to mild dehydration. In moderation, there is little to worry about; but        heavy consumers of caffeine may find a faster flow of fluids through        their body, requiring a greater consumption of non-caffeinated liquids.
      In a 2000 survey conducted for Rockefeller University and the International        Bottled Water Association, 2,818 adults in 14 cities reported drinking        about 6 cups of water a day—a result that was presented as alarming        evidence that Americans are becoming dehydrated. But if you include the        sodas, coffee, tea, milk, juice, sports drinks, and alcoholic beverages        these respondents drank, their average fluid consumption was 17.6 cups        a day—enough to have you urinating every waking hour, even if you        don’t have any problem with bladder capacity.
      More recently, a kidney specialist at Dartmouth Medical School searched        the scientific literature for studies that might support the idea that        people need 8 glasses of fluid a day. Not only did he determine that        no such evidence exists, but concluded that the research that has been        done "strongly suggests that such large amounts are not needed."
      Fluids and incontinence      If you have an incontinence problem, the below tips might help improve        your symptoms. Unless you engage in strenuous exercise or have a medical        condition (such as a propensity toward forming kidney stones) that requires        more fluid consumption:
      Aim for no more than 6–8 cups of fluid (from all sources) each        day.
      Don’t drink more than 8 ounces at a time.
      Don’t guzzle. The faster your bladder fills, the more likely you        are to feel urgency.
      Minimize caffeinated and carbonated drinks.
      Decrease or eliminate alcohol consumption.
      If you are thirsty because it is hot or you have exercised, don’t        hesitate to drink water.

http://www.health.harvard.edu/healthbeat/HEALTHbeat_091405.htm#art1
发表于 2012/2/19 17:27:13 | 显示全部楼层
我只知道一天喝八杯水会撑死我,所以我不喝、、、、
发表于 2012/2/19 18:51:51 | 显示全部楼层
据说明朝军队是每人带4升水,不运动出汗的人当然喝不了。
发表于 2012/2/19 20:11:48 | 显示全部楼层
8杯水的背后是无数盲目的群众
还有今天说8杯,明天又推翻8杯的叫兽们...

饮食有节--<内经>
发表于 2012/2/19 21:32:00 | 显示全部楼层
站长好。闻晨起一杯水。不知合理乎?
发表于 2012/2/20 02:37:26 | 显示全部楼层
西方人喜欢量化,还是因人而异具体情况具体对待为宜。
发表于 2012/2/20 04:37:58 | 显示全部楼层
david92003 发表于 2012/2/19 17:19
欢迎大家转载!
一天喝八杯水到底是哪个损人的主意?哈佛大学带我们追寻历史!

這事看人﹐口不渴也不想喝水而勉強硬灌﹐對身體肯定害多益少﹐口渴了不喝水肯定也不好﹐喝水多少因人而異。西方醫學沒有一個個體醫學﹐所以屢出千人一方的餿主意。一般﹐喝水少而不渴﹐可能是脾臟濕阻﹐應該先去除體內濕濁﹐之後身體自然會比較喜歡喝水﹐多喝點也無害﹐但是別喝冷水﹐傷脾胃可不好玩
发表于 2012/2/20 10:19:29 | 显示全部楼层
本帖最后由 stoneandmin 于 2012/2/20 10:20 编辑

有时候我一天就喝几口水,有时候一暖水瓶不够喝,反正想喝的时候就喝
发表于 2012/2/20 17:42:46 | 显示全部楼层
自从艾灸后,一般情况下都没有觉得口渴,一天都不喝水,除非打球劳动之类才喝点水。
发表于 2012/2/20 18:17:35 | 显示全部楼层
我喝水可勤快了.喝完一杯又去接一杯.
您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 立刻加入

本版积分规则

小黑屋|手机版|民间中医网论坛 ( 黔ICP备19001372号 )

GMT+8, 2024/4/20 11:17

Powered by Discuz! X3.4

© 2001-2023 Discuz! Team.

快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表